Chairman Emeritus of Tata Sons, Ratan Tata, today said shifting the Nano car plant from Singur in West Bengal was a prudent move in hindsight but gave the group a high negative cost.

“In hindsight, it was a prudent decision given the hostile circumstances in Singur. But that move gave us a high negative cost,” Tata said at an interaction organised by the Ladies Study Group of Indian Chamber of Commerce.

Tata, who took the decision to shift the Nano plant from Singur in 2008, was the Chairman of Tata Sons then and retired two years back.

“When we created the Nano, there was a lot of global excitement that a car could be offered at a price of $2,500 and three lakh orders with a waiting period of two years was induced.”

“But it took another year because of the shift and there was a general disbelief generated about the car, while competitors got a chance to start bad—mouthing the Nano. By that time, much of the excitement was lost,” he said.

Praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Tata said he was grateful to him for giving Nano a home at Sanand in Gujarat.

On West Bengal

Talking about West Bengal, he said he faced a serious problem (referring to Singur) which was not related to labour.

“We had to take the decision that we cannot operate in the hostile situation and had to move out the car factory to another state.

“You can pull the trigger of the gun or take it away. But the head will not move,” he quipped.

Asked to comment on the change in the state compared to two years back, he said, “While driving from Rajarhat, it is unbelievable to see new buildings coming up. But it still looks like a countryside, undeveloped. I do not see much signs of industrial development.”

On Modi

Ratan Tata termed Prime Minister Narendra Modi as a ‘doer’ and said he should be given more time.

“Modi has a track record of being a doer. Gujarat is an example and one should go there to see it,” said Tata.

He said that since 1984, there was a paradigm shift in India’s democracy with a political party getting single majority, unlike coalition government or a minority government.

But the government machinery had now shifted to “quick acting and growth—oriented (work) rather than government—oriented”, Tata said.

“We should given them more time.”

'I’m not cut-out for politics'

Ratan Tata said he never considered politics in his life like his mentor JRD Tata and added that he was not cut-out for that.

“Like my mentor JRD Tata, I had never considered politics. I am not cut-out to be political person and will not venture into it. The water there is very very deep,” he said.

Asked how he would be liked to be remembered, Tata said, “I would like to be remembered as somebody who had never hurt others and done work to the best interest of business.”

Related Topics