CAG to audit banks getting money under recap scheme

With the belief that “every penny counts, especially if it is public money”, government auditor Comptroller & Auditor General (CAG) is set to start scrutinising the public sector banks that have received financial aid from the government.

“The audit will essentially look at whether the money given by the government (Finance Ministry) to these banks as part of recapitalisation has been utilised correctly. Since it is government money, the CAG is within its rights to audit it. Besides, it also forms part of auditing the Finance Ministry’s accounts,” a senior government official told BusinessLine.

One of the major challenges before Finance Minister Arun Jaitley and his team has been to improve the overall performance of public sector banks, which have suffered mainly due to the sharp rise in bad loan provisioning.

In the last five years, the Finance Ministry has infused over ₹85,000 crore (2011-16) in PSU banks.

An official in the know said the government auditor is at present working on internal guidelines to decide on the term of the audit, the process to be followed etc.

The CAG proposes to complete the audit and submit its report during the 2017 Monsoon Session of Parliament.

While it is true that the Centre has been committing funds to ensure that PSBs are sufficiently capitalised to meet Basel III norms, it is also a fact that in the last two years banks appear to have used the money mostly to absorb losses on account of the steep rise in bad-loan provisioning.

The Finance Ministry has been annually altering the criteria for deciding on the capital infusion into various banks, making it difficult to assess how effectively banks have deployed the capital.

For instance, this year it has decided to base it on the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of credit for the last five years and banks’ own projections of credit growth as well as growth potential.

SBI, Indian Overseas Bank, Punjab National Bank, Bank of India and Central Bank of India figured at the top of the list. But, barring SBI, which has delivered annual loan growth of 14 per cent in the last five years, others have not shown potential for growth.

Central Bank of India and Indian Overseas Bank, for instance, delivered only 7-8 per cent growth (annual) in loans over the past five years.

Under the Indradhanush plan, the Centre has proposed to infuse ₹70,000 crore of capital between 2015-16 and 2018-19. It arrived at the figure by assuming 12 per cent credit growth in 2015-16 and 12-15 per cent growth for the subsequent years.

But credit growth for the entire banking sector has been languishing at decadal low levels of 8-9 per cent for over two years now. For PSU banks, the growth has been even more abysmal, slipping to about 3 per cent in 2015-16.

“Questions were being raised on the utilisation of these funds. There are some who believe that the banks are not using the money for rightful purpose,” said another official.

Mostly, the infusion over the years has been need-based, in banks that are in dire need of capital to grow and meet their regulatory requirements.

Many PSU banks have been consolidating their loans and turning averse to corporate lending. The loan book has, in fact, shrunk for many lenders in the last one year.

Bank of Baroda, for instance, has seen its loan book shrink by 10 per cent in 2015-16 after registering modest growth of 7.8 per cent in 2014-15.