The prosecution’s attempt to restrain the special 2G court from releasing the attached properties and execution of bail bond of Maran brothers — Dayanidhi and Kalanithi — after their discharge in the ₹742.58 crore Aircel-Maxis deal cases today met with probing questions from the Supreme Court.
A bench headed by Chief Justice J S Khehar was not in an agreement with the grounds taken by senior advocate Anand Grover, who was appointed by the apex court as special public prosecutor (SPP), to lead the prosecution on behalf of CBI and the Enforcement Directorate, saying that the discharge of the accused made it clear that this case was not of moneylaundering as alleged by ED.
“The simple logic is that this money (₹742.58 crore), considered to be that of laundering, is not found to be that of the proceeds of the crime,” the bench, also comprising Justices NV Ramana and DY Chandrachud, said during the hearing in which the SPP was also told that he has not cured many of the defects in the plea which was raised in the morning.
However, when Grover tried to press for the relief in the absence of proper appeal filed either by CBI or ED, the bench said as per the special court’s order, this money was not a “part of the crime” alleged against the accused and this being so, then “there was no money laundering”.
Hearing on Feb 8
The bench gave an opportunity to the SPP to “prepare” his case and “address arguments on Wednesday”.
Before the matter was posted to February 8, Grover tried to explain that why he himself moved the apex court without waiting for ED to file an appeal against the order of the special court which held that no case of conspiracy was made out against any of the accused persons in the case.
Grover said that ED will file a proper appeal after consultation and approval but due to urgency in the matter, he has moved the apex court with only two prayers that the bail bonds should not be executed and the attached properties should not be released.
He said that CBI will also take his opinion and his juniors would prepare a draft which will finally go to the Law Ministry for vetting.
The bench asked Grover as to why he didn’t approach the Delhi High Court with a revision petition as the issue of bail bonds is a too trivial.
Grover said that as per earlier orders of the apex court, only after the final order in the 2G cases could parties approach the high court and all the interim orders pending completion of trial would be dealt with by the Supreme Court.
However, the apex court disputed his contention that the discharge in the case cannot be considered as the final order.
He also made it clear that if CBI does not file appeal against the discharge of Maran brothers, then the NGO Bhushan is representing will step in.
The bench concluded the hearing by asking the SPP to prepare a fresh petition so that there should not be any objections and it has to be filed by tomorrow.
Krishnan, Marshall summoned
The court made it clear that T Ananda Krishnan, Ralph Marshall of Malaysia’s Maxis Group against whom summons were issued in the Aircel-Maxis case must appear.
If the accused don’t respond to summons and appear before the court here, it will not be open for them to raise objections in the case of monetary loss, it warned.
The apex court made it clear that if the Malaysian businessmen did not reply to the summons, it might order auction of spectrum allotted to Aircel-Maxis to recover ₹20,000-crore debt.
It allowed Aircel time till Wednesday to make clear all points on the Aircel-Maxis deal and posted the matter for hearing next Friday.
The SunTV stock jumped 23.92 per cent to close at ₹683.85 on the BSE. During the day, it zoomed 26.66 per cent to ₹699 — its 52-week high.